One wrong GQM input, missed shell-game read, or step onto a red tile can ruin a near-complete 400-Secret run. Follow the clean route: scan the Church organ, rescue Eddie Burlow, clear five escalating hostage rooms, then use the maintenance tunnels to take down Edward Nigma without triggering a hostage failure.

Before You Enter: Secret Gates, Gadgets, and Failure-Proof Setup

Track this progression before entering any room. The 400 Secrets total includes Riddler trophies, riddles, physical challenges, and Catwoman trophies.

Target Gate Location
Adam Hamasaki 0 Park Row
William North 80 Industrial District
Dr. Chen 160 The Bowery
Holly White 240 Industrial District
Anne Bishop 320 Amusement Mile
Edward Nigma 400 Bowery, near the Museum

Collect the late-room kit before committing to a run: Freeze Blast and REC for Dr. Chen, the Cryptographic Sequencer and Line Launcher for Holly White, and the Triple Line Launcher for Anne Bishop. Use Detective Mode to read heat signatures, safe paths, and targets, but pause before every GQM activation; several rooms punish a blind input immediately.

The Enigma Conundrum Walkthrough: Church, Courthouse, and First Hostage Room

Scan the pipe organ at the back of the Church to solve the opening riddle and reveal Solomon Wayne Courthouse. Defeat the courtroom thugs, speak with Eddie Burlow, and take the Enigma Machine; align its wheels to SECRET for the radio riddle.

Reach Adam Hamasaki in Park Row and use the following safe route:

  1. Hit the first GQM above the entrance.

  2. From a safe panel, Batarang the far-wall GQM to disable the first electrified section.

  3. Advance only after the next safe panel appears, then hit the second far-wall GQM.

  4. Step onto the elevator and activate the third GQM to raise it.

Never test a red glowing tile. One damage cycle can end this room, so Batarang each visible far-wall question mark before crossing.

Batman navigating Riddler electrified hostage room

Arkham City Hostage Rooms 2–5: Every Trap Solution

  • William North — 80 Secrets, “SHADOW”: Enter the room, activate Detective Mode, and follow the hostage’s heat signature through the three-cup shell game. When the cups stop, hit only the GQM beneath the cup containing the final signature; a wrong selection kills William.

  • Dr. Chen — 160 Secrets, “MIRROR”: Use Freeze Blast to make an ice float, pull across with the Batclaw, then fire REC at the industrial magnets to shift the hanging obstacles. Finish with the Line Launcher across the gaps, checking Detective Mode before each landing.

  • Holly White — 240 Secrets, “DARKNESS”: Hack the console with the Cryptographic Sequencer, watch the spinning blade-roller pattern, and sprint-slide beneath the rollers. Use the Line Launcher over electrified floors, changing direction mid-air when required; the Tightrope upgrade makes this timing safer.

  • Anne Bishop — 320 Secrets, “PENNY”: Fire REC to move the boxes, then use the Triple Line Launcher to chain shots around corners without touching the floor. Finish by Quick-Firing Batarangs at the final GQMs before the force fields reset.

Final Riddler Takedown and the Best Version to Revisit

At 400 Secrets, enter Nigma’s Bowery hideout near the Museum. Do not walk across the explosive main floor: enter the maintenance tunnels through the grates, follow beneath the moving hostages, and stay directly under Riddler until a floor Takedown becomes available. The bombs detonate if the hostages stop moving, so patience matters more than speed.

Confirm that all five medics survived and that Catwoman’s trophies are included in the Secret total; if every hostage lived, no room replay is required. In 2026, Arkham City still draws roughly 1,100–1,300 concurrent Steam players, and PC remains the usual modding and high-frame-rate pick. Players checking the GOTY listing can use Steam: Batman Arkham City GOTY, while the PriceRadar Batman: Arkham City tracker is useful when waiting instead of paying the standard $19.99 listing price.